⭐Gr 6 Up–Twelve-year-old Sully lives on a small island in Maine, where he and his buddies know a great deal about lobstering; good lobsters are keepers, while others are throwbacks that are tossed back for another time. Readers travel back in alternating sections with seven-year-old blond Sully as he shows his childhood rife with homelessness, food scarcity, and a mom with substance-use disorder. Sully battles his extreme moods, which he calls the Sads and the Mads, as he is separated from his mother and placed into foster care. Sully now lives with his foster mom, Miss Millie, and his foster brother, Victor. Sully and his island friends spend the summer kayaking, camping, and playing softball, but Sully still worries about his mom, and wonders if she still thinks of him. Sully grows to discern and trust the people who are there for him versus those who have let him down, and like a lobster shedding its shell, he is eventually ready to grow and have something bigger—a family—if Miss Millie can adopt him and Victor. Debut author Pedro is a former high school teacher, a dad, and a foster dad, who brings readers along on a tough journey filled with anger and loss but also hope and love.
VERDICT Readers will feel compassion and empathy for Sully and the cards he has been dealt but will also recognize his resilience in this definite keeper of a (lobster) tale.
—School Library Journal
"If Throwbacks and Keepers was only a book about the delights of island life in Maine, I would urge you to read it. If it was only a book about the power of community in our fragmented world, I would urge you to read it. If it was only a book about a determined and courageous kid who resists the effects of neglect, I would urge you to read it. That it is all of these, and tied together with a fascinating structure, should send you out to the bookstore this afternoon."
—Gary D. Schmidt, Newbery Honor winner and National Book Award finalist.
“Ron Pedro’s Throwbacks and Keepers is a beautifully nuanced and empathetic depiction of one boy’s experience with foster care and a realistic portrayal of Maine island life. You can’t help but root for protagonist Sully. Despite all that life throws at him, Sully builds resilience, grows his friendships and also finds his way to joy. An ultimately hopeful and resonant story with both humor and heart.”
—Betty Culley, award-winning author of Landslide
“Throwbacks and Keepers is a deeply moving story. Ron Pedro gets it right: the waiting, the anger, and the loss. Sully's journey from stormy childhood to a life in calmer seas will leave readers thinking hard about what makes a place, and a people, feel like home.” —Marpheen Chann, Public Servant and Author of Moon in Full
“Throwbacks and Keepers is a tender, beautifully layered story of a boy making his way through foster care, searching for the place and the people where he might finally belong. Ron Pedro moves gracefully between past and present, revealing Sully’s story piece by piece, with empathy, humor, and a deep understanding of how complicated the definition of family can be. As a Maine islander, I especially loved the way the island itself becomes part of the story: its rhythms, its fierce sense of community. I read this alongside my daughter Simone, who loved it too—a generous, hopeful book about the many ways we find and make a home.”
—Mira Ptacin, author of Poor Your Soul and The In-Betweens: The Spiritualists, Mediums, and Legends of Camp Etna
“Throwbacks and Keepers by Ron Pedro is definitely a keeper and a remarkable debut. Sully’s journey is filled with twists and turns, with Mads and Sads, but mostly it is filled with heart. Sully will weave his way into your heart. He’s a keeper too even though his early life with a struggling mother and then his time in the foster care system make him wonder if he is worthy of a family and a home and love. Cliff notes version: He is worthy. Pair this with One for the Murphys by Lynda Mullaly Hunt for discussions, understanding, and inclusion of foster children.”
—Lynn Plourde, Katahdin Award winner and author of The Bionic Boy